Man says police wrongfully arrested him, used excessive force when removing him from a Tim Hortons
In proceedings alleging wrongful arrest and excessive force arising from an incident when police removed a man from a Tim Hortons, the Ontario Court of Appeal ordered a new trial limited to his malicious prosecution claim.
In his action against the Durham Regional Police Services Board and two constables, the respondent in Sanayhie v. Durham (Police Services Board), 2026 ONCA 813, alleged:
In January 2025, a jury tried the action. In its initial verdict, the jury awarded no damages for wrongful arrest or excessive use of force. While the jury found no liability for malicious prosecution, it fixed damages for that claim.
Upon identifying an inconsistency, the trial judge issued a re-instruction asking the jury to reconsider the original verdict.
After around 20 minutes of deliberations, the jury returned with a second verdict, which found liability for malicious prosecution and imposed damages in the same amount as in the first verdict.
The appellants moved for judgment in their favour pursuant to the first verdict, which did not deem them liable for malicious prosecution.
On June 26, 2025, Justice Michael K. McKelvey of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice dismissed the appellants’ motion and entered judgment according to the second verdict.
The Ontario Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and set aside the trial judgment in connection with the malicious prosecution claim and the associated damages, including the punitive damages and legal costs.
The Ontario Court of Appeal characterized the first verdict as unclear and thus unsafe.
The appeal court also described the second verdict as unsafe, given that the trial judge’s re-instruction unnecessarily suggested that the jury find malicious prosecution, thus assuming an outcome.
The appeal court took issue with the inclusion of the following words in the re-instruction: “presumably based on the finding of a malicious prosecution.”
The Ontario Court of Appeal pointed out that the jury instructions did not track the jury questions. The appeal court added that the trial judge failed to explain that his prior instruction was inconsistent with the verdict sheet’s words.
“There is a risk, in this case, that the trial judge’s initial instructions were not properly understood and his comments on re-instruction improperly influenced the jury in completing their role as finders of fact,” wrote Justice Peter D. Lauwers for the appeal court.
Emphasizing the need for a more careful approach, the appeal court explained that the re-instruction:
On Apr. 27, the Superior Court ordered the entry of a judgment pursuant to a jury verdict declining to award any damages in favour of the plaintiff in an action for injuries allegedly sustained when mall security guards arrested him for trespass.
On Feb. 10, the Superior Court dismissed an application filed by a tenant who alleged that police officers had unlawfully arrested and used excessive force against her when responding to a call from her landlady, who claimed the tenant had assaulted her.
Enjoy this story? Read the latest personal injury law news on the main page!