Superior Court certifies COVID-19 class action against Huron Lodge

Plaintiffs alleged gross negligence in long-term care home’s pandemic response

Superior Court certifies COVID-19 class action against Huron Lodge
Windsor, Ontario

In an action alleging gross negligence in the Huron Lodge long-term care (LTC) home’s COVID-19 response, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice certified a class proceeding upon applying the requirements in s. 5(1) of Ontario’s Class Proceedings Act, 1992. 

In Adamo v. City of Windsor, 2026 ONSC 6174, the defendant owned, licensed, and operated the Huron Lodge. 

In their proposed class action, the plaintiffs sought to represent classes of individuals who had allegedly experienced serious and preventable harm due to the defendant’s delayed, ad hoc, and insufficient response to the COVID-19 pandemic at the Huron Lodge. 

The plaintiffs proposed the following common issues: gross negligence, causation, and damages and remedies. 

Specifically, the plaintiffs asserted that the defendant was grossly negligent in responding to the pandemic at the Huron Lodge, which underwent multiple COVID-19 outbreaks from Jan. 25, 2020, to May 5, 2023, leading to: 

  • the COVID-19 infections of at least 1,966 residents 
  • the deaths of at least 244 residents from COVID-19 

Superior Court certifies the class proceeding

The plaintiffs moved to certify their proposed class action. The defendant agreed to the certification. 

Upon certifying the action as a class proceeding, the Superior Court designated the plaintiffs as the classes’ representative plaintiffs and appointed their counsel as class counsel. 

The class period would run from Jan. 25, 2020, to May 5, 2023, the date of the Public Health Agency of Canada’s statement that the World Health Organization had announced that COVID-19 no longer amounted to a public health emergency of international concern. 

Cause of action in gross negligence

First, the Superior Court ruled that the plaintiffs asserted a reasonable cause of action focusing on gross negligence. The court explained that the ruling in Pugliese v. Chartwell, 2024 ONSC 1135: 

  • recognized this cause of action for COVID-related cases against LTC homes 
  • stated principles relevant to characterizing the defendant as operating as a single enterprise relating to infectious disease policies and their implementation 

Identifiable classes

Second, the Superior Court discerned some factual basis for identifiable classes. The plaintiffs had proposed class definitions for: 

  • the “Residents,” the “Resident Class,” and the “Resident Class Members” 
  • the “Visitors,” the “Visitor Class,” and the “Visitor Class Members” 
  • the “Family Law Act Class” and the “Family Law Act Class Members” 

Common issues

Third, the Superior Court found some factual basis for the plaintiffs to allege that the Huron Lodge was ripe for outbreaks due to chronic, long-standing deficiencies in connection with: 

  • the outdated, physically neglected, and overcrowded facility 
  • inadequate infection prevention and control (IPAC) training and protocols 
  • systematic failures to inspect and oversee the LTC home’s compliance with the relevant regulatory, legal, and industry standards 
  • understaffing 

The court also saw some factual basis for the plaintiffs to claim that the defendant: 

  • implemented reactive, delayed, and deficient IPAC measures that did not align with the LTC sector’s and the medical community’s current knowledge about the nature of COVID-19 and its risks to the elderly and other vulnerable populations, despite recognizing its obligations to observe the proper guidance and best practices to prevent exposing the Huron Lodge’s elderly residents to infection and death 
  • could have prevented the COVID-19 outbreaks and saved lives if it had not breached its common-law obligations to the class members in the years leading to and during the pandemic 

The Superior Court concluded that the claims clearly shared factual and legal similarities. 

Class action as the preferable procedure

Fourth, the Superior Court found some factual basis supporting that a class proceeding was the preferable procedure for resolving the common issues, given: 

  • the number of class members 
  • the economics of pursuing this type of claim 
  • the need for expert evidence 

The court added that a class action would assist in: 

  • ensuring a just, expeditious determination 
  • promoting judicial economy 
  • seeking behaviour modification 

Representative plaintiffs

Lastly, the Superior Court saw some factual basis that the plaintiffs: 

  • could fairly and sufficiently represent their respective classes’ interests 
  • could produce a workable plan for advancing the classes’ claims 
  • would not, on the common issues, have an interest conflicting with their fellow class members’ interests 

More news on COVID-19 class actions against long-term care homes

On June 5, the Superior Court preferred the more flexibly defined period proposed by the plaintiff for a claim in the class proceeding concerning the Huron Lodge LTC home’s IPAC processes. 

In a case alleging gross negligence in the operation of licensed LTC home Oakwood Park during the pandemic, the Superior Court issued a Mar. 17 ruling certifying the plaintiffs’ class proceeding and designating them as representative plaintiffs. 

Enjoy this story? Read the latest personal injury law news on the main page!