Superior Court doesn’t find school board liable for teacher’s abuse

Judge assesses general damages at $200K for grooming, sexual violence

Superior Court doesn’t find school board liable for teacher’s abuse
Ontario Superior Court of Justice

The Ontario Superior Court of Justice dismissed a claim for damages against a school board upon determining that it was not liable for an incident involving a teacher’s sexual assault of a student who was then 13 years old. 

In C.P.G. v. Dufferin-Peel Catholic District School Board, 2026 ONSC 6046, the plaintiff studied at an elementary school from September 1957 to June 1966 and at a secondary school from September 1966 to February 1972. 

In January 1964, R.G.W. began working for a school board that was a predecessor of the defendant school board. Between January and June 1964, he taught the sixth grade at the plaintiff’s elementary school, which was under the defendant school board. 

From September 1966 to February 1967, R.G.W. taught the eighth grade at another school within the same school board. He became that school’s acting principal in November 1966, then resigned from the defendant school board in February 1967. 

In 2003, in a proceeding in which the plaintiff was the complainant, a court found R.G.W. guilty of indecent assault committed between Sept. 4, 1964, and June 30, 1965, under s. 148 of the Criminal Code. 

Claim for damages

The plaintiff asked the Superior Court to order the defendant school board to pay damages for negligence and breach of fiduciary duty. Specifically, he sought general damages ranging from $200,000 to $275,000, as well as damages for past income loss. 

According to the plaintiff, if the sexual assault had not happened, he would have finished the 13th grade, gone to university, and pursued a vocation that would have been more personally and financially rewarding than his firefighting work. 

R.G.W.’s liability

Accepting the plaintiff’s evidence, the Superior Court determined that R.G.W.: 

  • taught the plaintiff English in the sixth or seventh grade 
  • paid the plaintiff special attention, including by taking him on outings and having him at his apartment 
  • sexually assaulted the plaintiff at his apartment at a time he was his English teacher and his mentor 
  • pled guilty to the assault in court proceedings 

Citing common sense, the court stated that the plaintiff would not have gone to the principal’s office and described R.G.W. as “a homo” after the incident if R.G.W. had not been teaching at his school at the time. 

Judge doesn’t deem the school board vicariously liable

In considering whether the defendant school board was vicariously liable, the Superior Court applied the test in Bazley v. Curry, 1999 CanLII 692 (SCC), [1999] 2 SCR 534. 

The court ruled that the case satisfied the test’s first prong because the plaintiff’s English teacher was R.G.W., who had a sufficiently close relationship with the school board. 

Regarding the test’s second prong, the court saw no sufficient connection between the sexual assault and R.G.W.’s assigned English-teaching tasks to constitute a materialization of the risks created by the enterprise, such that the school board might be vicariously liable. 

“Indeed, in my view, the only connection is one of a “but for” liability link, namely that, but for R.G.W.’s employment with the school board, the assault would not have happened,” wrote Justice Pamela L. Hebner for the court. 

Superior Court assesses general damages at $200K

Accepting the evidence of the plaintiff’s medical expert, the Superior Court held that the assault resulted in mild to moderate psychological impairment for the plaintiff. 

“This is a case of a single incident of sexual violence after R.G.W. groomed the plaintiff over months,” Justice Hebner wrote. “The assault took place when the plaintiff was a child at an impressionable age.” 

The court acknowledged the tort’s profound impacts on the plaintiff, who: 

  • had difficulty dealing with authority figures 
  • had trouble in his marital and other relationships 
  • showed hypervigilance with his own children 
  • experienced stress headaches 
  • turned to marijuana 
  • developed a Valium addiction 
  • formed a prejudice against homosexual men, which manifested as physical violence at times 
  • kept his trauma a secret for many years 

Punitive damages

However, the Superior Court awarded no punitive damages against the defendant school board, which had not engaged in egregious conduct. 

Past income loss

Upon considering the evidence, the Superior Court found no justification for a past income loss claim, which the plaintiff had failed to establish. 

According to Justice Hebner, the plaintiff “had a highly successful 28-year career in firefighting. There is no evidence that he would have pursued any other career at the time had the assault not occurred.” 

Lastly, the court permitted the parties to file written cost submissions. 

More Ontario cases involving schools

Last May 21, the Superior Court approved a $60-million settlement of a class proceeding against the provincial government on behalf of those placed into provincially operated training schools. 

On Nov. 12, 2025, the Ontario Court of Appeal denied an appeal of a decision dismissing an action alleging that a school board and two school officials were liable in negligence for a 10-year-old student’s injury sustained during a bullying incident. 

Enjoy this story? Read the latest personal injury law news on the main page!