Virtual mediations now a reality

The past year has revealed the advantages and disadvantages of the online approach

Virtual mediations now a reality
Margaret K. Rees, of YORKSTREET Dispute Resolution Group, outlines the advantages and disadvantages of going virtual.

Sponsored content

Everything changed in March 2020. Stores and restaurants closed, courts closed and mediations, long set, were cancelled.

Before too long however the courts and mediations resumed virtually. That was a year ago. How has the world of virtual mediation evolved since? Margaret K. Rees, C. Med, of YORKSTREET Dispute Resolution Group Inc., outlines the advantages and disadvantages that the last year has revealed.

ADVANTAGES

There is no doubt that there is an ease of attendance, sitting at one’s computer with no travel involved at all. Some might even argue that there is a degree of relaxation with a reduced dress requirement. How many mediations have been conducted whilst wearing a jacket, shirt or blouse along with unseen track pants and fluffy slippers? We’ll never know.

There is a certain degree of cost effectiveness too as there is no meeting room, breakout space, parking or office requirement along with no travel or flight expense. Add to this a more casual approach to the presentation of the parties: perhaps even a reduction in the “intimidation factor” that can unnerve some plaintiffs who are now in familiar surroundings, in “their own space” and comfort zone. These surroundings may, in turn, produce an enhanced ability to focus on the matter to hand.

Obviously there is less tendency for parties to arrive late and there is an increased efficiency with less “small talk” around the table. I’ve found too that, given a lack of physical presence, there is less opportunity for in-session conflict.

DISADVANTAGES

There is, without doubt, a reduced ability to clue into nuances and body language — for example an increased inability of the parties to “size each other up.” What kind of a witness will he or she make? There is always the potential too for technical difficulties or interruptions though, in my experience, this has not really been a factor yet.

All the parties are, when virtual, on the “honour system” for in session privacy but, in reality, nobody knows if there are others present off camera. There is also a decided lack of exercise for the mediator who is no longer required to shuttle between meeting rooms. This can lead to a post-mediation frenzy of cookie consumption.

I suggest that it’s an unknown whether or not the mediator’s influence is somewhat curtailed by the lack of a physical presence. It’s certainly easier to be persuasive when all are physically present. There is as well always the possibility of a lack of focus if the parties aren’t physically together in one room for a plenary session. They may be more easily distracted by what’s happening in their immediate surroundings. A child, or even a cat or dog, may present such a distraction.

Despite the aforementioned disadvantages, based on my experience of the last year virtual mediations, with their ease and success ratio, may well be here to stay —  to some degree anyway.

Related stories

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Long term care home residents greatly impacted by COVID detention measures.: Advocacy lawyer

Judge accused of bias rejects disbarred lawyer's motion to overturn dismissed appeal

Evidence obtained at photo line-ups ruled admissible in robbery case

Mother brought children to Ontario and refused to return home to UAE, order to return stayed: court

Auto insurers' profit increase during COVID demonstrates need for transparency: lawyer

Donation of $12,000 to promote urban studies efforts at Windsor Law

Most Read Articles

Ontario's top court stays decision in case involving Indigenous child in need of protection

Hearsay probative value must be measured against prejudicial effect and not by case strength: ONT CA

Auto insurers' profit increase during COVID demonstrates need for transparency: lawyer

Tenant ordered to pay rent arrears after COVID-19 restrictions triggered force majeure clause