Minister justified in using alternative method given failure of registrant to maintain trustworthy records

Tax court of Canada | Tax | Goods and Services Tax | Administration and enforcement

Given absence of documents Minister assessed using alternative verification method based on employees’ salaries. Minister assessed registrant for GST and penalties. Registrant appealed. Appeal allowed in part. Salary verification method was accepted method. Minister justified in using alternative method given failure of registrant to maintain trustworthy records. Irrelevant that registrant sometimes replaced other employees without remuneration. Adjustments made to assessment because of errors in number of hours worked and days restaurant open. Minister justified in imposing penalty. Registrant and his accountant admitted that not all taxable supplies reported. Registrant knew report false and was grossly negligent in not reporting proper amount.

Langheit c. La Reine (2017), 2017 CarswellNat 7392, 2017 CCI 250, Johanne D’Auray J. (T.C.C. [General Procedure]).

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

OCA says paralegal didn’t provide ineffective assistance after failing to file materials for appeal

OCA finds bank breached data contracts, tried to ‘suppress the truth’ in litigation

Arbitrator upholds firing of employee who came to work while feeling ill in early days of COVID-19

Ontario Court of Appeal orders security for costs of over $115,000 in dispute over legal fees

Ontario Superior Court transfers motor vehicle accident cases to Ottawa from North Bay

OCA orders redaction, declines full sealing order requested by Muslim organization, in tax dispute

Most Read Articles

OCA says paralegal didn’t provide ineffective assistance after failing to file materials for appeal

OCA orders redaction, declines full sealing order requested by Muslim organization, in tax dispute

Ontario Court of Appeal partly allows insurer's appeal in case alleging injury suffered at concert

Arbitrator upholds firing of employee who came to work while feeling ill in early days of COVID-19