Despite trial judge’s errors, trier of fact would inevitably have entered conviction

Supreme court | Jury

Deliberations

Despite trial judge’s errors, trier of fact would inevitably have entered conviction

Accused was charged with first degree murder and attempted murder. Trial judge refused to admit in evidence out-of-court statements made by one victim and gave instruction with respect to fabrication of alibi. Accused was eventually convicted on both counts. Accused appealed against his convictions. Majority of Court of Appeal held that trial judge erred in not admitting in evidence out-of-court statements and in giving jury instruction with respect to fabrication of alibi. However, majority found that deference was owed to trial judge’s decision to give instruction in that regard. Concluding that case against accused was overwhelming, they applied curative proviso of s. 686(1)(b)(iii) of Criminal Code and confirmed convictions. Accused appealed as of right to Supreme Court of Canada. Appeal dismissed. Instruction trial judge gave with respect to fabrication of alibi was erroneous. Trial judge should specify in such instruction that fabrication of alibi would support inference of consciousness of guilt, but no more than that. Instruction in this case did not satisfy this requirement. Moreover, there should be other evidence independent of finding that alibi was false on basis of which reasonable jury could conclude that alibi was deliberately fabricated and that accused was involved in that attempt to mislead jury. However, despite trial judge’s errors, evidence in case at bar was so overwhelming that trier of fact would inevitably have entered conviction against accused. Therefore, convictions were upheld.
R. c. Laliberté (Apr. 29, 2016, S.C.C., McLachlin C.J.C., Cromwell J., Wagner J., Gascon J., and Brown J., 36712) Decision at 126 W.C.B. (2d) 478 was affirmed. 129 W.C.B. (2d) 153.


Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from Law Times.

Recent articles & video

Charter issues come to fore on defence of extreme cases of intoxication

Statement of principles media coverage prompts boycott of new bencher

Ontario increases claim limit for Small Claims Court

Clients want lawyers to stop ignoring emails and phone calls

Law professor Anita Anand elected as MP for Oakville riding

CCLA’s Michael Bryant calls for ban on facial recognition surveillance

Most Read Articles

New real estate law podcast begins by tackling cannabis regulations

Legal aid investments save governments money all over the world, Canadian researchers find

Clients want lawyers to stop ignoring emails and phone calls

After 22 years under Les Viner, Torys names new leader