Accused acquitted of sexual assault as complainant not reliable witness

Ontario criminal | Criminal Law | Offences | Sexual interference

TS was mother of complainant SL. TS met accused in church and they became romantically involved. Shortly after their relationship commenced complainant claimed that accused touched her vagina in church basement on several occasions. Complainant was between four and six years old when alleged offences occurred. Police were contacted after relationship between TS and accused ended. Accused was charged with sexual interference. Complainant was under 16 years old at time of offence. Accused acquitted. TS was not credible witness. Court had no difficulty with complainant’s credibility but it had problems with her reliability. Court was not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that accused ever touched complainant with sexual purpose in mind. Court was also not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that complainant was ever sexually touched by anyone.

R. v. W. (B.) (2017), 2017 CarswellOnt 4048, 2017 ONSC 1774, M. Fairburn J. (Ont. S.C.J.).

 


Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Law Society Convocation approves new policy on bencher information requests

Relocation disputes surge in family law litigation, says Lerners LLP’s Ryan McNeil

Ont. CA confirms future harm risk not compensable in contaminated medication class action

Law Commission of Ontario announces new board of governors appointments

Ontario Superior Court upholds ‘fair dealing’ in franchise dispute

Ontario Superior Court orders retrial for catastrophic impairment case due to procedural unfairness

Most Read Articles

Relocation disputes surge in family law litigation, says Lerners LLP’s Ryan McNeil

Law Commission of Ontario announces new board of governors appointments

Ontario Superior Court denies late motion to transfer car accident case to simplified procedure

LEAF celebrates 39 years fighting gender-based discrimination at annual Evening for Equality gala