Accused’s silence not evidence of guilt

Supreme court | Charter of Rights


Accused’s silence not evidence of guilt

Accused not testifying at joint trial with co-accused. Co-accused’s counsel submitting to jurors accused’s failure to testify evidence of his guilt. Trial judge holding co-accused’s closing remarks prejudiced accused, undermined right to silence. Trial judge declining to give remedial instruction, holding s. 4(6) of Canada Evidence Act precluded reference to accused’s silence. Court of appeal holding trial judge erred, s. 4(6) only prohibited comments prejudicial to accused, not limiting instruction requested. Court of appeal upholding convictions, holding error harmless. Accused’s further appeal dismissed. Section 4(6) of Canada Evidence Act did not preclude affirmation for right to silence, which should be done where realistic concern jury may place evidential weight on accused’s decision not to testify. Jury entitled to take into account evidence uncontradicted in assessing reliability, credibility of Crown’s case. Co-accused’s counsel ought not to have made comment concerning accused’s failure to testify. Co-accused could have relied on fact he testified to argue he was innocent, had nothing to hide but not to invite jury to use accused’s silence as evidence of accused’s guilt. Explicit remedial instruction from trial judge would have been preferable. Trial judge’s charge functionally adequate to impart message Crown could prove accused’s guilt only on evidence, accused’s silence not evidence of guilt.
R. v. Prokofiew (Oct. 12, 2012, S.C.C., McLachlin C.J.C., LeBel, Deschamps, Fish, Abella, Rothstein, Cromwell, Moldaver and Karakatsanis JJ., File No. 33754) Decision at 256 C.C.C. (3d) 355; 88 W.C.B. (2d) 702 was affirmed. 104 W.C.B. (2d) 190.

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Upcoming FACL conference focused on AI’s impact on profession, advancing careers of Asian lawyers

Legal Innovation Zone launches program to help legal tech entrepreneurs turn ideas into businesses

Law Foundation of Ontario forms strategic partnership with Indigenous Peoples Resilience Fund

Ontario Superior Court upholds the College of Physiotherapists’s authority over billing inaccuracies

Housing supply needs more public-private collaboration, less red tape, say lawyers

Judicial vacancies holding up construction litigation: litigators

Most Read Articles

Ontario Court of Appeal resolves access rights between parents and maternal grandparents

Ontario Court of Appeal upholds dismissal of statute-barred personal injury claim

Judicial vacancies holding up construction litigation: litigators

With new federal funding Pro Bono Ontario expanding program for Ukrainian nationals across Canada