Misapprehended evidence relied on to make crucial credibility assessments at trial

Ontario criminal | Appeal

GROUNDS

Misapprehended evidence relied on to make crucial credibility assessments at trial

Trial judge convicted accused of sexual assault of neighbour’s five-year-old daughter. Complainant testified during horseplay where accused blew on children’s stomachs he performed oral sex on her. Accused denied sexual contact but admitting to nature of horseplay with children. Forensic expert testified deposits of accused’s DNA found in complainant’s underwear but not from external vaginal swab. Forensic expert testified secondary transference of DNA to underwear could not be ruled out. Trial judge stated in reasons she agreed with expert DNA could not have been deposited to underwear other than through oral sex on complainant. Trial judge using finding concerning forensic evidence to bolster credibility of complainant and reject evidence of accused. Appeal allowed and new trial ordered. Trial judge critically misapprehended forensic evidence by stating deposit could only have been through oral sex and wholly ignored negative result of vaginal swab. Misapprehended evidence relied on to make crucial credibility assessments at trial. Correctly apprehended forensic evidence tended to bolster accused’s admission to non-sexual oral contact with children. Forensic evidence tended to undermine complainant’s evidence oral sex occurred.
R. v. C. (M.M.) (Apr. 23, 2014, Ont. C.A., Alexandra Hoy A.C.J.O., H.S. LaForme J.A., and G. Pardu J.A., File No. CA C54917) 112 W.C.B. (2d) 788.

Free newsletter

Our daily newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please complete the form below and click on subscribe for daily newsletters from Law Times.

Recent articles & video

80% of legal employers prefer technical skills to personality

Torys’ Linda Plumpton named to American College of Trial Lawyers

Pressure mounts for immigration lawyers working with Latin American clients

$100K prize offered by Canadian legal tech start-up

New Toronto legal clinic offers Korean-language services

BLG grows tax group with new counsel Andrea Dickinson

Most Read Articles

OPP charges former tax lawyer with fraud and obstruction of justice

New facets of pure economic loss rule could have huge implications for businesses

Does solicitor-client privilege protect information shared with a legal app?

Court addresses the denial of dependent support for egregious conduct