Inspection as invasive as that proposed ought not to be undertaken simply on basis of suspicion

Ontario civil | Civil Procedure

DISCOVERY

Inspection as invasive as that proposed ought not to be undertaken simply on basis of suspicion

Respondent filed motion for order that court appoint computer forensic expert to examine computer systems of applicant and its principal, and order that employees or agents of applicant assist expert with all reasonable requests to fulfill its mandate. Respondent wanted expert to verify whether two e-mails between applicant’s principal and third party were authentic. Applicant’s position was that the e-mails were not authentic, were never exchanged, and did not appear in its system. Motion dismissed. Motion judge accepted applicant’s submission that no trace of e-mails was found following forensic investigation of its devices. Nor was any trace or e-mails found during execution of Anton Piller orders. Inspection as invasive as one proposed by respondent ought not to be undertaken simply on basis of suspicion, speculation or conjecture. Order sought by respondent was disproportionate and unnecessary, and value to be gained through order proposed was limited.
Direct Energy Marketing Ltd. v. National Energy Corp. (Jun. 11, 2013, Ont. S.C.J., J.S. O’Neill J., File No. CV-11-431862) 233 A.C.W.S. (3d) 331.

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Relocation disputes surge in family law litigation, says Lerners LLP’s Ryan McNeil

Ont. CA confirms future harm risk not compensable in contaminated medication class action

Law Commission of Ontario announces new board of governors appointments

Ontario Superior Court upholds ‘fair dealing’ in franchise dispute

Ontario Superior Court orders retrial for catastrophic impairment case due to procedural unfairness

LEAF celebrates 39 years fighting gender-based discrimination at annual Evening for Equality gala

Most Read Articles

Ontario Superior Court confirms License Appeal Tribunal cannot award punitive damages

Ontario Court of Appeal denies builder's request for a trial on damages in a real estate dispute

Ontario Superior Court grants extension for service of expert reports in medical negligence case

Relocation disputes surge in family law litigation, says Lerners LLP’s Ryan McNeil