Tribunal not unreasonable in dismissing appeal based on failure to attend

Ontario civil | Administrative Law | Requirements of Natural Justice | Bias

Applicant was former instructor at respondent university. Instructor claimed that she was not properly accommodated during her employment at university. Instructor also claimed harassment by one of her supervisors. Instructor filed internal complaint against university, but was not successful. Instructor filed three separate proceedings after dismissal of complaint. One proceeding was under Labour Relations Act, another was application for judicial review, and third was application against university and arbitrator. All proceedings were dismissed as against instructor, with costs. Appeal hearing was scheduled at Human Rights Tribunal in 2015. Instructor claimed that she would not attend hearing, due to medical condition and allegations of bias. Hearing proceeded in instructor’s absence, with appeal being dismissed. Reconsideration application of this decision was also dismissed. Instructor applied for judicial review of tribunal decisions. Application dismissed. Allegations of bias were completely unfounded. Allegations were made against all decision-makers, without any supporting evidence. Reconsideration decision being made by same person as original decision was proper procedure. No bias was present in reconsideration process. Tribunal was not unreasonable in dismissing appeal, based on failure to attend. Tribunal was acting within its own established rules and procedures when it dismissed appeal. Court would have acted in similar way to dismiss action, had matter been before court.

Taucar v. Ontario (Human Rights Tribunal) (2017), 2017 CarswellOnt 6295, 2017 ONSC 2604, Anne Molloy J., C.J. Horkins J., and J. Paul R. Howard J. (Ont. Div. Ct.).

 

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Judges resume hearings at Milton courthouse after voicing concerns about mould and asbestos

Regional law group applauds Fort Frances courthouse judge being hired after decade-long gap

Norton Rose names Jennifer Teskey as Canadian managing partner

Ontario Superior Court of Justice upholds 'competence-competence' principle in commercial dispute

Woman injured in car accident with rental vehicle not covered by insurance: Ontario Superior Court

Lincoln Alexander law school's new legal clinic to take a community-based approach: program director

Most Read Articles

Lincoln Alexander law school's new legal clinic to take a community-based approach: program director

Judges resume hearings at Milton courthouse after voicing concerns about mould and asbestos

Woman injured in car accident with rental vehicle not covered by insurance: Ontario Superior Court

Lincoln Alexander School of Law welcomes Justice Catrina Braid as judge in residence