Record before motion judge was inadequate, deficient and controversial

Insurance – Actions on policies – Practice and procedure

Infant plaintiffs were catastrophically injured when struck by vehicle driven by defendant SP at defendant LP' plaza. Motion judge ordered SP to pay all plaintiffs' partial indemnity costs of $927,934.08, without any contribution from SP, but net of an agreed upon contribution by City of Windsor. SP appealed, challenging motion judge's apportionment of liability for damages as basis for apportioning costs following settlement. Appeal allowed in part and liability for plaintiffs' costs re-allocated. Motion judge erred in undertaking an assessment of respective liability of defendants for plaintiffs' damages in order to apportion costs. Costs were not always apportioned in accordance with co-defendants' respective liability with respect to damages. Judge did not have proper record to carry out apportionment of liability between defendants. Permitting adjudication of parties' respective liability for damages following settlement would be counter to purpose of settlements and trial fairness. Record before motion judge was inadequate, deficient and controversial for purpose of determining liability for damages. Motion judge's apportionment of costs was set aside. Appropriate and fair apportionment of costs was that defendants contribute equally to and are held jointly and severally liable for plaintiffs' costs, given that they contributed equally to settlement.

Bondy-Rafael v. Potrebic (2019), 2019 CarswellOnt 21131, 2019 ONCA 1026, P. Lauwers J.A., K. van Rensburg J.A., and L.B. Roberts J.A. (Ont. C.A.).

Case Law is a weekly summary of notable civil and criminal court decisions by the Supreme Court of Canada, the Federal Court of Canada and all Ontario courts. These cases may be found online in WestlawNext Canada. To subscribe, please visit

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

E-Hearings Task Force in Ontario shares best practices for remote hearings

Appeal leaves questions about fiduciary duty in clinical trials

Halton courthouse project halted, with funds repurposed to modernize justice system amid COVID-19

Mid-sized law firms could be in toughest position, says Thomson Reuters CEO

Former Superior Court judge Romain Pitt dies at 84

Tribunal system ‘in crisis,’ group says

Most Read Articles

Teresa Donnelly, Philip Horgan nominated for Law Society of Ontario treasurer

Tribunal system ‘in crisis,’ group says

How to lay out law firms, post-COVID social distancing

Alternative to bar exam, PREP, launches in June for Alberta, Manitoba, Nova Scotia, Saskatchewan