Member's delay in commenting about language not raising reasonable apprehension of bias

Ontario civil | Real Property | Landlord and tenant | Residential tenancies

Board found that tenant refused to permit landlord to enter her apartment as required by lawful Notice of Entry in order to assess extent of repair work requested by tenant. Board member concluded that tenant's conduct substantially interfered with landlord's reasonable enjoyment of residential complex. Member ordered termination of tenancy and eviction of tenant. Tenant appealed, with central allegation being that member was biased. Appeal dismissed. Allegations did not come close to satisfying high standard required to displace presumption of impartiality. Transcript did not show member denying tenant right to present evidence of past negative conduct of landlord. It was not established that member exclusively offered superintendent opportunity to seek adjournment; member had no obligation to offer, far less to order, adjournment. It was open to member to refrain from commenting on what he considered to be racially insensitive comment made by superintendent, who was oblivious to offence it gave. Member's delay in commenting about language did not raise reasonable apprehension of bias. It was open to member to conclude that superintendent's actions were not motivated by racism. Fact that member referred to tenant as “tenant” and referred to other individuals by their initials did not raise reasonable apprehension of bias; member consistently used terms “landlord” and “tenant”, referring to all other individuals by their initials.

Read v. Alto Properties Inc. (2019), 2019 CarswellOnt 5658, 2019 ONSC 1451, M. Dambrot J., Wilton-Siegel J., and Emery J. (Ont. Div. Ct.).


Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Ruling gives 'clearer directions' on assessing limitations period in disability cases, say lawyers

Trafficking convictions tossed after trial judge takes four years to release reasons for judgment

Toronto Lawyers Association confers Award of Distinction on Louise Arbour

Arbitrator rules on sick pay entitlement of workers isolated due to possible COVID-19 exposure

Panel to discuss role of litigation and regulation in managing justice system use of AI

Ontario avoided public consultation in making decisions with environmental impact: auditor general

Most Read Articles

Law Society of Ontario defers vote on eliminating mandatory minimum wage for articling students

Court clarifies role of public correction in secondary market misrepresentation claims

Panel to discuss role of litigation and regulation in managing justice system use of AI

Expectation of materialization not a factor in determining contingent interest in land: court