Conduct of defendants in dealings with plaintiffs was shabby and high-handed

Ontario civil | Civil Procedure

COSTS

Conduct of defendants in dealings with plaintiffs was shabby and high-handed

Defendants sought costs. Action was certified as class proceeding. Plaintiff class consisted of 171 AO pilots and defendant class consisted of 1,617 AC pilots. Plaintiffs alleged that members of defendant class committed torts of conspiracy, intentional interference with economic interests and negligent misrepresentation. They alleged that defendant class owed fiduciary duty to members of plaintiff class, which was breached. Defendants were successful in resisting action. Defendants sought costs of $1.5 million. Application dismissed. This was not test case and it did not involve matter of public interest. Procedural nature of action was unique and action engaged some novel points of law. However, it could not be said that action raised novel point of law for purposes of invoking application of s. 31(1) of Class Proceedings Act, 1992 (Ont.). Award that defendants bear own costs was fair and reasonable in circumstances of case. Defendants were successful and made offers to settle, but their conduct in dealings with plaintiffs was shabby and high-handed. Defendants did not deserve costs award in their favour. Fair and reasonable disposition was for defendants to bear own costs.

Berry v. Pulley (Sep. 3, 2013, Ont. S.C.J., Pepall J., File No. 97-CV-135179 CP) Additional reasons to 218 A.C.W.S. (3d) 993. 232 A.C.W.S. (3d) 46.

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Liberal MPP’s bill aims to ‘depoliticize’ and clear backlog from Ontario’s tribunal system

Ontario Superior Court awards damages after real estate deals fail due to broker's conflicting roles

Ontario Superior Court rejects jury trial in motor vehicle accident case due to procedural delays

Court of Appeal addresses wrongful conviction risk in 'Mr. Big' police stings

Empathy, human connection, and creativity separate lawyers from AI systems, says Tara Vasdani

Karen Perron named as associate justice of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice

Most Read Articles

School boards' lawyer suing social media platforms hopes trial reveals inner workings of algorithms

Court of Appeal addresses wrongful conviction risk in 'Mr. Big' police stings

Karen Perron named as associate justice of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice

Ontario Superior Court upholds human rights tribunal's authority over workplace disputes