Officer did not have discretion to act for oblique motive

Federal court | Citizenship

OFFENCES

Officer did not have discretion to act for oblique motive

Adoptive father adopted two teenagers. Quebec Court recognized adoption judgment rendered in Haiti. Applicant received letter indicating citizenship application was granted. Clerical error happened and citizenship application was ultimately refused nearly two years later. Applicant was convicted of offences and removal order was made against applicant. Applicant was permanent resident. Applicant’s application for citizenship for person adopted by Canadian citizen was refused. Applicant’s adoption was found not to comply with rules of country where adoption took place because Institute not Social Affairs Officer approved adoption. Application for judicial review was allowed. Decision was unreasonable. Citizenship officer did not personally verify procedures that applied in Haiti and in Quebec at time of applicant’s adoption. Authenticity of adoption judgment and applicant’s Haitian birth certificate were not in issue. Evidence on record showed officials were uneasy about applicant’s criminality and were working toward outcome. Officer engaged in selective reading of evidence and ignored all evidence submitted in support of citizenship application. Final judgment of foreign court became res judicata particularly since judgment received judicial recognition in Quebec. Applicant was legally adopted. Argument that adoption was entered primarily for purpose of acquiring status was pretext. Adoption was in best interests of child and created genuine parent-child emotional bond. Parental authority of biological parents was transferred to adoptive father. Officer did not have discretion to act for oblique motive or to not approve citizenship application that otherwise met conditions of legislation.
Dufour c. Canada (Minister de la Citoyenneté et de l’Immigration) (Apr. 4, 2013, F.C., Luc Martineau J., File No. T-802-12) 231 A.C.W.S. (3d) 41.

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Ontario court says Toronto litigants are increasingly 'forum shopping,' filing cases in London

Legal Aid Ontario releases final report on Aboriginal Justice Strategy

Ontario Superior Court extends asset freeze in favour of insurance company in mortgage fraud dispute

Ontario Superior Court absolves landlords from liability in municipal sidewalk slip and fall case

Toronto lawyer Kathryn Marshall opens plaintiff-side human rights and employment firm

Ontario Superior Court orders new hearing after pedestrian was denied fairness in car accident case

Most Read Articles

Ontario court says Toronto litigants are increasingly 'forum shopping,' filing cases in London

Toronto lawyer Kathryn Marshall opens plaintiff-side human rights and employment firm

Ontario Superior Court orders new hearing after pedestrian was denied fairness in car accident case

Ontario Superior Court absolves landlords from liability in municipal sidewalk slip and fall case