Tribunal considered material outside formal record on motion

Federal appeal | Human Rights Legislation

APPEALS

Tribunal considered material outside formal record on motion

This was appeal of Federal Court’s decision setting aside decision of human rights tribunal. Respondents brought complaints under Canadian Human Rights Act, alleging that Canada had engaged in prohibited discrimination by under-funding child welfare services for on-reserve First Nations children and denied them services available to other Canadian children. Respondent commission referred complaint to tribunal. Appellant brought preliminary motion alleging that complaint could not succeed. Tribunal held that complaint could not succeed under s. 5(b) of Act and quashed complaint. Federal Court set aside tribunal’s decision. Federal Court found that decision was substantively unreasonable and was procedurally unfair. Appeal dismissed. Federal Court appreciated test for reasonableness and applied it differentially. Federal Court found that tribunal’s interpretation of s. 5(b), which required complainants to point to similarly situated comparator group in order to succeed, was unreasonable. Federal Court did not err in finding that tribunal’s decision was unreasonable. Federal Court found that it was unreasonable for tribunal not to consider s. 5(a) of Act and Federal Court’s analysis was unimpeachable. Complaint referred globally to s. 5 and s. 5(a) was part of complaint. Tribunal considered material outside formal record on motion. Tribunal committed procedural unfairness in circumstances. Parties were entitled to know what tribunal was considering and to have opportunity to address it.
Canada (Human Rights Commission) v. Canada (Attorney General) (Mar. 11, 2013, F.C.A., David Stratas J.A., J.D. Denis Pelletier J.A., and Wyman W. Webb J.A., File No. A-145-12) Decision at 215 A.C.W.S. (3d) 439 was affirmed.  226 A.C.W.S. (3d) 813.

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

OBA Innovator-in-Residence Colin Lachance aims to help lawyers integrate AI into their practice

Ontario Superior Court rejects mining company’s breach of agreement and confidentiality claims

Ontario Superior Court orders plaintiff to pay substantial costs despite injury claims

Labour and employment lawyer Muneeza Sheikh opens her practice as part of 'building a brand'

Ontario Superior Court awards damages in domestic assault case due to defendant's default

Ontario Privacy Commissioner calls for stronger access and privacy protections

Most Read Articles

Labour and employment lawyer Muneeza Sheikh opens her practice as part of 'building a brand'

Ontario Superior Court awards damages in domestic assault case due to defendant's default

Ont. Superior Court upholds Human Rights Tribunal's denial of reconsideration in discrimination case

Ontario Privacy Commissioner calls for stronger access and privacy protections