Taxpayer failed to provide evidence or opinion on how values could be extrapolated back to decade ago

Tax court of Canada | Tax | Income tax | Tax credits

Taxpayer donated 21 bottles of wine made up of different labels and vintages to two charities and charities appraised fair market value of bottles at $22,600 over decade ago. None of wines were available at Liquor Control Board of Ontario (LCBO). Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) reassessed taxpayer and assigned value of $4,700, which represented about 20 per cent of amounts receipted by charities. Taxpayer’s expert calculated, based on global wine seller’s 2016 prices, that prices for wines were $5,500 and CRA’s expert valued known sales based on wine auctions available to taxpayer as resident in Ontario, over decade ago, at $2,650. Taxpayer appealed. Appeal dismissed. Critical problem with taxpayer’s expert’s valuation was that she did not provide evidence or opinion on how her values could be extrapolated back to decade ago. Since Ontario had actual, lawful and available real markets in which resident wanting to obtain as high price as possible for bottle of wine could participate, there was no need to consider creating proxy marketing to evaluate value of bottles of wine. CRA’s expert evidence was from completed auction sales at single large U.S. consignment auction house, and this amount was far inferior to values used by CRA in reassessments. Accordingly, appeal had to be dismissed, as CRA could not be ordered to reassess using lower value than used in reassessments.

McCuaig Balkwill v. The Queen (2018), 2018 CarswellNat 2849, 2018 TCC 99, Patrick Boyle J. (T.C.C. [General Procedure]).

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Court overturns robbery and firearm convictions because Charter breach undermined trial fairness

Employers should focus on proactive steps on mental health, not just legal requirements: lawyer

Ontario Superior Court dismisses insurance claim over water damage incident in a restaurant

Ontario Superior Court approves settlement for victim of fatal traumatic brain injury

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Legal Aid Ontario appoints Fallon Melander as AVP of the new Indigenous Services Department

Most Read Articles

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Ontario Superior Court orders insurer to disclose documents in fatal motor vehicle collision case

Waivers in Ontario: Are they legally binding?

Ontario Superior Court grants bankruptcy order over unsettled million-dollar debt