Failure to attend trial was not presumptively after-fact conduct

Supreme court | Criminal Law | Appeals | Appeal from conviction or acquittal

Accused, charged with sexual assault of two complainants, was released on bail. After accused’s surety was revoked, he failed to attend scheduled start of trial. Accused was arrested on unrelated matter and, after first trial resulted in mistrial, second trial judge held voir dire on admissibility of failure to appear as post-offence conduct showing consciousness of guilt. Trial judge refused to allow accused to testify on voir dire and found evidence of his failure to appear was admissible, providing instructions to jury that it could only be considered as supporting inference of guilt if they decided that there was no other explanation for such conduct. Accused’s appeal was allowed, with majority finding that trial judge erred in conduct of voir dire and in content of instruction. Dissenting judge found that accused’s counsel’s summary of proposed voir dire evidence provided sufficient factual foundation for trial judge to make informed decision on relevance and that trial judge’s instruction was adequate as it reviewed competing explanations for conduct. Crown appealed. Appeal allowed. Failure to attend trial was not presumptively after-fact conduct but rather had to be assessed on case-by-case basis. Appeal would be allowed substantially for reasons of dissenting judge.

R. v. J.M. (2019), 2019 CarswellOnt 6228, 2019 CarswellOnt 6229, 2019 SCC 24, 2019 CSC 24, Abella J., Karakatsanis J., Côté J., Rowe J., and Martin J. (S.C.C.); reversed (2018), 2018 CarswellOnt 21543, 2018 ONCA 1054, J.C. MacPherson J.A., Grant Huscroft J.A., and I.V.B. Nordheimer J.A. (Ont. C.A.).

Case Law is a weekly summary of notable civil and criminal court decisions by the Supreme Court of Canada, the Federal Court of Canada and all Ontario courts. These cases may be found online in WestlawNext Canada. To subscribe, please visit store.thomsonreuters.ca.

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Court overturns robbery and firearm convictions because Charter breach undermined trial fairness

Employers should focus on proactive steps on mental health, not just legal requirements: lawyer

Ontario Superior Court dismisses insurance claim over water damage incident in a restaurant

Ontario Superior Court approves settlement for victim of fatal traumatic brain injury

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Legal Aid Ontario appoints Fallon Melander as AVP of the new Indigenous Services Department

Most Read Articles

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Ontario Superior Court orders insurer to disclose documents in fatal motor vehicle collision case

Waivers in Ontario: Are they legally binding?

Ontario Superior Court grants bankruptcy order over unsettled million-dollar debt