Accused acquitted of refusing to provide breath sample on basis that constable had no reasonable grounds to demand sample

Ontario criminal | Criminal Law | Offences against the person and reputation | Refusing to provide breath or blood sample

Constable stopped vehicle after seeing it weaving, detected odour of alcohol emanating from accused’s breath, and formed reasonable suspicion that accused had alcohol in his body. Constable testified that he asked accused to accompany him to cruiser, produced Approved Screening Device (ASD), and demanded that accused provide breath samples into “approved instrument,” which he was not able to do despite trying for 15 minutes. Counsel for both parties agreed that if constable’s intention was to conduct roadside screening, he should have commanded accused to provide breath sample into “approved screening device”. Accused was acquitted of refusing to provide breath sample on basis that at time of demand, constable did not have reasonable grounds to demand sample into “approved instrument”. Crown appealed acquittal. Appeal dismissed. Trial judge made no legal error in requiring appellate intervention in acquitting accused. Trial judge clearly identified that it was essential element of offence that lawful demand was made upon accused.

R. v. Egbeobawaye (2019), 2019 CarswellOnt 2573, 2019 ONSC 1370, Mulligan J. (Ont. S.C.J.); affirmed (2018), 2018 CarswellOnt 7075, 2018 ONCJ 297, Marcella Henschel J. (Ont. C.J.).


Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Court overturns robbery and firearm convictions because Charter breach undermined trial fairness

Employers should focus on proactive steps on mental health, not just legal requirements: lawyer

Ontario Superior Court dismisses insurance claim over water damage incident in a restaurant

Ontario Superior Court approves settlement for victim of fatal traumatic brain injury

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Legal Aid Ontario appoints Fallon Melander as AVP of the new Indigenous Services Department

Most Read Articles

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Ontario Superior Court orders insurer to disclose documents in fatal motor vehicle collision case

Waivers in Ontario: Are they legally binding?

Ontario Superior Court grants bankruptcy order over unsettled million-dollar debt