Hybrid approach to determining habitual residence under Hague Convention should be adopted

Supreme court | Conflict of Laws | Family law | Children

Parties married in Ontario, moved to Germany where they acquired permanent residence status and had two children. Parties agreed that mother would take children to Ontario where they would attend school until August 2014. Father commenced application under Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, 1980 (Hague Convention) and original consent agreement lapsed. Application judge requested involvement of Office of Children’s Lawyer (OCL) and ordered return of children to Germany. On appeal, it was found that children’s habitual residence had changed. Father’s appeal was allowed and order of application judge was restored. OCL applied for leave to appeal. Children were returned to Germany where custody was granted to mother and children were returned to Canada. Although events had rendered appeal moot, issues raised in appeal were important and law required clarification. Hybrid approach to determining habitual residence under Article 3 of Hague Convention and non-technical approach to considering child’s objection to removal under Article 13(2) should be adopted. Principle of harmonization supports hybrid approach and hybrid approach best conforms to text, structure and purpose of Hague Convention. 

Office of the Children’s Lawyer v. Balev (2018), 2018 CarswellOnt 6096, 2018 CarswellOnt 6097, 2018 SCC 16, 2018 CSC 16, McLachlin C.J.C., Abella J., Moldaver J., Karakatsanis J., Wagner J., Gascon J., Côté J., Brown J., and Rowe J. (S.C.C.); affirmed (2016), 2016 CarswellOnt 14331, 2016 ONCA 680, Laskin J.A., Robert J. Sharpe J.A., and B.W. Miller J.A. (Ont. C.A.).

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Court overturns robbery and firearm convictions because Charter breach undermined trial fairness

Employers should focus on proactive steps on mental health, not just legal requirements: lawyer

Ontario Superior Court dismisses insurance claim over water damage incident in a restaurant

Ontario Superior Court approves settlement for victim of fatal traumatic brain injury

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Legal Aid Ontario appoints Fallon Melander as AVP of the new Indigenous Services Department

Most Read Articles

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Ontario Superior Court orders insurer to disclose documents in fatal motor vehicle collision case

Waivers in Ontario: Are they legally binding?

Ontario Superior Court grants bankruptcy order over unsettled million-dollar debt