Major deficiency in proposed class action was failure to satisfy preferable procedure criterion

Ontario civil | Civil Practice and Procedure | Class and representative proceedings | Representative or class proceedings under class proceedings legislation

Hospital operated drug testing laboratory between 2005 and 2015 and during that time tested hair of 18,463 individuals to screen for presence of drugs and alcohol. Of 18,463 individuals tested, total of 10,004 were reported as having positive result and 6,958 of reported positives were individuals referred from child protection agencies. Proposed representative plaintiff was one of individuals tested and, following positive test results, her child remained in foster care for approximately two years. Proposed class action was commenced. Proposed representative plaintiff brought motion for certification of proposed class action. Motion dismissed. Major deficiency in proposed class action was its failure to satisfy preferable procedure criterion. Procedural and substantive access to justice would invariably require individual issues trials for class members with significant enough injury to justify expense of complex individual trials about liability. Individual issues trials were not amenable to any summary determination as contemplated by s. 25 of Class Proceedings Act, 1992. Common issues would not sufficiently advance claims of class members and combining common issues trial with individual issues trials made proceedings unmanageable and disadvantageous in comparison to alternative of individual actions. Class action was not preferable procedure for access to procedural justice. Given problems confronting substantive access to justice and problems of efficiency and productivity, and given what little would be accomplished by common issues trial, more efficient and expeditious way to adjudicate claims would be to proceed directly by way of individual actions.

Green v. The Hospital for Sick Children (2017), 2017 CarswellOnt 16865, 2017 ONSC 6545, Perell J. (Ont. S.C.J.).

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Court overturns robbery and firearm convictions because Charter breach undermined trial fairness

Employers should focus on proactive steps on mental health, not just legal requirements: lawyer

Ontario Superior Court dismisses insurance claim over water damage incident in a restaurant

Ontario Superior Court approves settlement for victim of fatal traumatic brain injury

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Legal Aid Ontario appoints Fallon Melander as AVP of the new Indigenous Services Department

Most Read Articles

Amid animal-related family law reform push, TMU launching pet law legal clinic

Ontario Superior Court orders insurer to disclose documents in fatal motor vehicle collision case

Waivers in Ontario: Are they legally binding?

Ontario Superior Court grants bankruptcy order over unsettled million-dollar debt