Minister paid lip service to reasoning of court

Federal appeal | Prisons

INMATES’ RIGHTS

Minister paid lip service to reasoning of court

Minister appealed court issued mandatory order requiring him within 45 days to accept prisoner’s transfer request and confirm in writing to prisoner that all reasonable steps had been taken for his prompt transfer to correctional facility in Canada. Prisoner, Canadian serving sentence in United States, appealed decision of Minister refusing such transfer. Minister found risk of commission of “criminal organization offence” in future was present. All other factors raised by evidence were in favour of transfer. On appeal, decision was quashed on grounds decision lacked in reasoning, was not transparent, and was intelligible. Decision was remitted back to Minister who again refused transfer; on appeal of that decision court found Minister paid lip service to reasoning of court, basically reasserted his previous reasoning, showed closed mind and intransigency. Order in question was then made. Minister alleged court was constrained and could only send matter back for reconsideration by Minister. Appeal dismissed. Order altered to compel Minister to accept transfer forthwith (45 days had elapsed). Costs of $8,900 granted. Courts below had found there was no evidence prisoner was at risk to commit criminal organization offence in future. Minister conceded this; with that factor off table all other factors pointed to granting transfer. In circumstances it was open to court to conclude on this evidence that only lawful exercise of discretion was granting of transfer; mandamus was appropriate. In circumstances mandamus was also available to prevent further delay and harm that would be caused to prisoner if Minister were given third chance to decide matter.
Lebon v. Canada (Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness) (Feb. 25, 2013, F.C.A., Sharlow J.A., David Stratas J.A., and Webb J.A., File No. A-39-13) Decision at 104 W.C.B. (2d) 769 was affirmed.  107 W.C.B. (2d) 396.    LT

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

From ignored to a nation-to-nation relationship: Jason Madden’s 20 years advocating for Metis rights

Ontario Superior Court of Justice welcomes new judges Colin Stevenson and Gilead Kay

Ontario Superior Court upholds award of costs exceeding the damages in a personal injury case

Ontario Superior Court resolves estate dispute between siblings by passing over a sister as trustee

Erika Chamberlain steps down as dean of Western Law

Ont. CA orders new trial in pedestrian collision case due to unfair bad character evidence

Most Read Articles

Erika Chamberlain steps down as dean of Western Law

Ont. CA orders new trial in pedestrian collision case due to unfair bad character evidence

From ignored to a nation-to-nation relationship: Jason Madden’s 20 years advocating for Metis rights

Ontario Superior Court of Justice welcomes new judges Colin Stevenson and Gilead Kay